Bills to hire more school counselors support Gov. Ducey’s safe schools plan - AZEdNews
Sections    Tuesday March 28th, 2023

Bills to hire more school counselors support Gov. Ducey’s safe schools plan


Bills this session that would help public schools hire more counselors are critical steps in implementing Gov. Doug Ducey’s Safe Arizona Schools plan.

The Safe Arizona Schools plan was developed last year with input from parents, teachers, students, principals, law enforcement, prosecutors and mental health experts around the state to prevent school shootings, after examining the five deadliest school shootings in the past 20 years.

Gov. Ducey’s proposed budget allocated a total of $12 million over two years to hire an additional 124 school counselors statewide, which would reduce the ratio of students to school counselors by 17 percent, said Janine Menard, chair of the Arizona School Counselors Association.

“That’s a great fresh start. We were very happy and excited that we were part of his proposed budget, but we know it’s not enough so we’re just kind of plugging away and getting out the word as best we can to get some public support for these bills,” Menard said.

Bills to hire more school counselors support Gov. Ducey’s safe schools plan KatherinePastorWStudentsInCounselingOfficeInside-1
2016 School Counselor of the Year Katherine Pastor talks to a student in the counseling office at Flagstaff High School. Photo courtesy of Flagstaff Unified School District

Bills include funding to hire more counselors

House Bill 2562, sponsored by Rep. Jennifer Pawlik, and Senate Bill 1344, sponsored by Sen. Sean Bowie, would help each school district and charter school hire at least one school counselor for every 550 students enrolled and would pay for that by appropriating a total $285 million from the state general fund over the course of five years.

Bills to hire more school counselors support Gov. Ducey’s safe schools plan janine-menard-350
Janine Menard, chair of the Arizona School Counselors Association

“Right now, Arizona has the worst in the nation ratio – we’re at 903 students to one counselor,” Menard said.

HB 2562 and SB 1344 would get that students to counselor ratio closer to the national average of 450 students to one counselor, Menard said.

“It’s good that we are looking at reducing the ratio of school counselors to students to 550 to 1,” said Chris Kotterman, director of governmental relations with Arizona School Boards Association. “We definitely appreciate that the mandate is contingent on funding provided, and we appreciate the resources dedicated to school counseling in the bill.”

About 44 percent of Arizona high school students do not have access to school counselors, according to the U.S. Department of Education’s Civil Rights Data Collection.

During the Great Recession, Arizona public schools made tough budget choices after the Arizona Legislature cut funding. Some reduced the number of counselors, while other eliminated school counselors completely.

Three years ago, Arizona determined that counselors and many other student and instructional support services  should be included in dollars spent in the classroom.

“Any school site that has counselors would agree that the kinds of support that counselors can provide for students and families is crucial for emotional health and academic success, and that those two things go hand-in-hand,” said Barbara Hickman, former superintendent of Flagstaff Unified School District in an earlier AZEdNews story about school counselors. “Counselors are an integral part of the ‘first line of defense’ for students in making sure that they are having outside needs met, that they feel safe and cared for, and that they have a web of support to help them grow up.”

Elementary and middle school counselors help all students through comprehensive counseling, teaching social-emotional learning, supporting students with their academics, helping students deal with trauma, mediating, advocating for students, attending Individual Education Plan and 504 meetings and using data to direct programs and interventions, Menard said.

“My ratio is even higher than the state average. I serve 1,100 students,” said Menard, a school counselor in the Isaac Elementary School District in a low-income area in Maryvale. “I’m in some classrooms once a month. Students may wait to see me for up to four days. The issues here will keep you up at night. It’s a lot.”

High school counselors help students choose courses to graduate and help them pursue their post-secondary education or career goals with college and career readiness, Menard said.

Bills to hire more school counselors support Gov. Ducey’s safe schools plan SchoolCounselorHP
Counselor Natasha Sankovich works with senior Blanca Aguirre on her college essay.

Counselors at all schools also support teachers, administrators, families as well as provide short-term counseling for students in need, Menard said.

“If we feel like the student needs long-term therapeutic support, we’ll refer them to an outside counseling agency,” Menard said.

Helping students with mental health issues is important, because many students come to school with a lot of trauma, and that can lead to negative outcomes in and outside the classroom and health problems, Menard said.

“Arizona has the highest rate of adverse childhood experiences (ACES) in the nation – 35 percent of students have experienced three or more,” Menard said.

That means students have difficulty focusing on their classwork,  because “what they have their mind on is “Is my Mom safe at home? Is my Dad going to get deported?” Menard said.

Neither bill has been heard yet in their respective education committees, but “we’re looking to mobilize and get some people to call to get this bill heard in the appropriations committee,” Menard said.