AZDHS amends COVID-19 school benchmarks - AZEdNews
Sections    Friday December 4th, 2020
Twitter Profile Facebook Profile LinkedIn Profile RSS Profile
| SUBSCRIBE

AZDHS amends COVID-19 school benchmarks


A Teacher Instructs One Group Of Her Students During Hybrid Or Modified In-person Instruction At Mesa Unified School District. Photo Courtesy Mesa Unified School District

Click here for updates 11/1 and moving forward

Updated 10/30: The Arizona Department of Health Services has updated its guidance to schools so that they may return to distance learning from hybrid or in-person instruction if just one of the key metrics is in the red or substantial category.

Arizona School Boards Association said it greatly appreciates the conversation and dialogue with partners at the state level, and especially the advocacy and concerns shared by all school board members, school leaders and education advocates during this time.

School leaders should continue to follow the plans carefully crafted by your district that you believe are the safest for your students and staff, ASBA said.

Arizona Superintendent of Public Instruction Kathy Hoffman said a communication breakdown between the Arizona Department of Health Services and the Arizona Department of Education “left the public confused and uninformed.”

“Yesterday, the Department of Health Services made clarifications to help clear this up. The important part is that these benchmarks provide schools with data-driven metrics, while schools maintain the ultimate authority to make decisions that are best for their communities,” Hoffman and Dr. Cara Christ, director of AZDHS said in a joint statement released today.

“Our goal is to move forward, together. It’s important for Arizona kids and families, and we look forward to continued collaboration during this pandemic and beyond.”

Updated 10/28: The Arizona Department of Health Services changed COVID-19 guidance for schools last week as cases substantially increased in the state, but few education advocates said they heard of the changes until this week.

On Wednesday afternoon, Arizona School Boards Association and Arizona School Administrators said in a statement, “This change was made without, to our knowledge, a concerted effort to communicate the reasoning for the change, or to understand the potential impact this change would have on district planning for the remainder of the year.”

Arizona School Administrators (ASA) is a professional organization representing 200+ districts across the state, and the Arizona School Boards Association (ASBA) is a voluntary membership organization composed of every school district in Arizona.

Both ASA and ASBA advocated for statewide benchmarks to guide school districts in determining the appropriate and safe learning environment for students and staff and applauded state leaders when these were released earlier this year. However, neither ASA or ASBA were included in discussions on the recent decision by AZDHS to change these recommendations regarding transitioning from hybrid to virtual instruction.

Previously, AZDHS recommended schools move from in-person or hybrid learning to remote or online learning if just one benchmark moved into the substantial spread or red category for two weeks in their Safely Returning to In-Person Instruction.

Now, AZDHS says school districts should move from hybrid or in-person learning to remote or online learning if all three of the benchmarks – cases, percent positivity and COVID-like illness, are in the red or substantial spread stage for two weeks.

AZDHS amends COVID-19 school benchmarks Updated-COVID-19-School-Benchmarks

That means schools could provide hybrid and in-person learning for a longer amount of time while COVID-19 cases increase in the community.

The change is “misguided” because school leaders decisions may now rely on a “flimsy” indicator that hospitals don’t have to report – Covid-like illness, said Will Humble, executive director of the Arizona Public Health Association to The Arizona Republic.

AZDHS says their recommendations provide guidance for school districts, but school district leadership has the final say in decisions on what type of instruction they choose to offer their students and families whether they’re community is in minimal, moderate or substantial categories.

These recommendations may place more stress on school district leadership and school district governing boards on when to move from online to in-person learning and back depending on what’s going on in their schools and their communities.

AZDHS Dr. Cara Christ said in a blog today that the changes were made to align the school recommendations in better alignment with the business recommendations on their dashboard, and made in response to concerns from partners in the Schools Reopening Workgroup about how a move back to virtual learning based on one benchmark would affect schools in smaller rural counties where a handful of cases could shift the percent positivity rate into the substantial category quickly.

On Oct. 16, the AZDHS informed the Schools Reopening Workgroup about the implementation of the revised guidance starting Oct. 22, and last week, posted the changes on its Schools webpage.

ASBA is not part of that workgroup.

“Arizona’s School districts made their plans for this school year based on guidance released by the Arizona Department of Health Services (DHS) in the summer,” ASA and ASBA said in a statement in response to the school benchmark changes.

That guidance outlined three conditions to monitor and identified certain thresholds as green, yellow, and red. It also stated that schools should start preparing for virtual learning if any one of the three benchmarks falls in the red category, indicating ‘substantial community spread’ of COVID-19.

“Administrators and school boards spent untold hours of planning and hours more of public meetings to develop these plans and get the 2020-2021 school year underway,” ASA and ASBA said.

The revised guidance recommends schools start preparing for virtual learning when all three benchmarks are in the red (substantial community spread) category. It states,  “If a county has all three benchmarks in the red category, they should prepare to transition to virtual learning, and consult with their local health department.”

“Ultimately, local governing boards and administrators retain the authority to protect student health and safety. ASA and ASBA encourage school districts to adhere to their original plans regarding moving to virtual learning if they feel that would best protect students and staff,” ASBA and ASA said

“Both organizations also strongly recommend that any changes or adjustments to these recommendations be thoroughly vetted with stakeholders and clearly communicated to schools with accompanying rationale before changes are made or implemented,” ASA and ASBA said.

On Monday, Superintendent of Public Instruction Kathy Hoffman released a summary of COVID-19 updates, guidance and news from the Arizona Department of Education.

Supt. Hoffman also spoke with ABC 15 Arizona’s Danielle Lerner about it.

Gov. Doug Ducey and Arizona Dept. of Health Services Director Dr. Cara Christ will hold a COVID-19 briefing Thursday at noon.

Fountain Hills Unified School District this morning closed their high school and asked students to quarantine for the next 14 days after a person on campus tested positive for COVID-19.

Confirmed COVID-19 cases in Arizona rose to 241,165 today from 240,122 yesterday, and 5,905 have died from the virus, said the Arizona Department of Health Services.

In Maricopa County, there are 155,951 confirmed cases of COVID-19, 27,962 in Pima County, 13,689 in Yuma County, 11,873 in Pinal County, 6,340 in Navajo County, 5,165 in Coconino County, 4,340 in Mohave County, 3,934 in Apache County, 3,004 in Santa Cruz County, 2,939 in Yavapai County, 2,150 in Cochise County, 1,914 in Gila County, 1,185 in Graham County, 618 in La Paz County and 101 in Greenlee County.

Interactive Graphic: (Hover over counties and boxes for more info)

Summary

Be Kind on the MOVE Mobile Classroom starts stopping by all Pendergast Schools today.

Teachers adapt to new ways of teaching with virtual instruction and more, says Tucson Values Teachers as they continue their work to ensure teachers are valued in the community.

Here are seven things all kids need in order for remote learning to be equitable, National Association of Elementary School Principals says.

Peoria Unified‘s Zuni Hills Elementary is holding a parade to honor a student as she begins some experimental treatment.

More than 750 Arizona teachers have resigned since the school year started and more than 320 of those said COVID-19 was the main reason they decided to leave the profession, The Arizona Republic reports.

Dysart Unified School District celebrates 100 years of educating students with 100 notable accomplishments.

Did you know this about school buses?

Today’s kindergarten students may feel the consequences of online learning for years to come, The Hechinger Report says.

Here’s a glimpse of Deer Valley Unified’s Sonoran Foothills students and staff during their school day.

Looking for an engaging election lesson? Take a look at some iCivics Slide Decks.

College Success Arizona suggests voters look at candidates stances on education issues in this election.

Arizona State University can help students prepare for the year’s number one career – data scientist.

Updated 10/27: The arts teach students that problems have more than one solution, Peoria Arts Education says.

Youth sports also help teach social, emotional and cognitive skills and well as build physical fitness, edutopia says.

Today is the last day to return your ballot by mail, after today drop off your ballot at a voting location or ballot drop box, Maricopa County Recorder Adrian Fontes says.

Confirmed COVID-19 cases in Arizona rose to 240,122 today from 238,964 yesterday, and 5,891 have died from the virus, said the Arizona Department of Health Services.

In Maricopa County, there are 155,458 confirmed cases of COVID-19, 27,703 in Pima County, 13,670 in Yuma County, 11,832 in Pinal County, 6,307 in Navajo County, 5,121 in Coconino County, 4,313 in Mohave County, 3,890 in Apache County, 2,995 in Santa Cruz County, 2,919 in Yavapai County, 2,125 in Cochise County, 1,907 in Gila County, 1,162 in Graham County, 616 in La Paz County and 103 in Greenlee County.

A Yuma Elementary School District One special education teacher shares how her students have progressed with remote learning.

K-12 teachers register now to learn best practices, find resources and get tips to support your remote teaching at Remote K12: The connected teacher summit, Arizona State University’s Dr. Michael Crow says.

Online and distance learning has led to changes in assessment practices in schools, National School Boards Association says.

Franklin at Brimhall Elementary‘s Rebecca Neal was named Arizona Health and Physical Education‘s Elementary PE Teacher of the Year.

Learn more about colleges, get 1-on-1 help filling out the FAFSA and college applications and learn more at Be a Leader Foundation‘s Taking Steps Towards College Success virtual event coming up soon.

Watch livestream broadcasts of Dysart School District events for free through Dysart Student Broadcasting Live.

Arizona Council on Economic Education says it’s never to early to teach personal finance.

Help your neighbors by taking part in Valley of the Sun United Way‘s virtual food drive from now until Nov. 6. More info below.

Tolleson Elementary School District‘s Lina Munoz was featured on Promising Practices last week with Maricopa County School Superintendent Steve Watson.

Updated 10/26: The Arizona Board of Education is meeting today and you can watch the meeting online. See below for more info.

The Arizona Board of Education adopted a rule to emphasize the importance of instruction on the Holocaust and other genocides. Learn more about the effort in an earlier AZEdNews story Holocaust education bill unanimously approved by House Education Committee.”

Confirmed COVID-19 cases in Arizona rose to 238,964 today from 238,163 yesterday, and 5,875 have died from the virus, said the Arizona Department of Health Services.

In Maricopa County, there are 154,722 confirmed cases of COVID-19, 27,575 in Pima County, 13,646 in Yuma County, 11,743 in Pinal County, 6,307 in Navajo County, 5,090 in Coconino County, 4,272 in Mohave County, 3,885 in Apache County, 2,981 in Santa Cruz County, 2,893 in Yavapai County, 2,121 in Cochise County, 1,863 in Gila County, 1,151 in Graham County, 613 in La Paz County and 102 in Greenlee County.

Morenci Unified School District Supt. David Woodall sent this letter to students’ families after COVID-19 cases increased recently.

Chandler Unified School District congratulates Sara Wyffels, who teaches Spanish at Chandler High School, for being named Arizona Educational Foundation‘s 2021 Arizona Teacher of the Year. Click here to read more about it.

Peach Springs Unified School District Teacher Ms. Burgess helps first graders learn the difference between statements and questions in a fun way!

Tuba City Unified School District celebrates Red Ribbon Week with dress up days and activities to help students stay healthy and drug-free.

Florence Unified School District students took part in a Paint the Bus event on a decommissioned school bus on Saturday, Oct. 24.

Avondale Elementary School District staff and students support mental health awareness among teenagers.

Blue Ridge Unified School District reminds students’ families and community members that they can earn an Arizona Tax Credit of up to $400 by donating to any public school’s program of your choice.

Humboldt Unified School District reminds students and families there are still two more opportunities to attend the virtual college and career fair. See more info below.

Looking for financial aid to help with your after-high school plans? Then apply for the AZEdNews Scholarship sponsored by The Brand Agency. More info below.

Updated 10/23: Watch the Arizona Educational Foundation‘s 2021 Arizona Teacher of the Year Award.

There have been 30 COVID-19 outbreaks at schools in Maricopa County since the school year started, Cronkite News reports.

Sunnyside Unified School District welcomes students back to campus.

The U.S. Centers for Disease Control now defines close contact as anyone within 6 feet of someone infected with COVID-19 for 15 minutes over the course of 24 hours and here’s what it means for schools, Education Week reports.

Confirmed COVID-19 cases in Arizona rose to 235,882 today from 234,906 yesterday, and 5,865 have died from the virus, said the Arizona Department of Health Services.

In Maricopa County, there are 152,695 confirmed cases of COVID-19, 27,297 in Pima County, 13,442 in Yuma County, 11,638 in Pinal County, 6,238 in Navajo County, 4,925 in Coconino County, 4,244 in Mohave County, 3,826 in Apache County, 2,968 in Santa Cruz County, 2,864 in Yavapai County, 2,098 in Cochise County, 1,830 in Gila County, 1,105 in Graham County, 611 in La Paz County and 100 in Greenlee County.

Marcos de Niza High School shares what science classes looked like in 1984 and today.

Today is the last day to request a mail-in ballot for the Nov. 3 elections, Arizona Secretary of State Katie Hobbs says.

Learn more about what Prop. 208 would do for schools before you vote, courtesy Cronkite News.

Mesa Public Schools shares resources for students and families to stay safe online.

Find out how arts education can help students language learning from Education News.

Peoria MET medical students gained insight from an Honor Health nurse on her career pathway.

The Graduate Wages Report shows the earning power of a college degree, the Arizona Board of Regents says.

Dysart Unified Supt. Quinn Kellis shares some highlights during School Bus Safety Week.

Teachers are being asked by schools to look for potential danger in the background of students taking classes online, Education Week reports.

Avondale Elementary School District‘s Migrant Education Program received a donation from Kiwanis of Litchfield Park to buy holiday presents for students.

Arizona State University alumni Brandon Slade who has ADHD founded Stride, a learning system to combine mentorship and movement to help students reach their goals.

Arizona Afterschool asks what’s been the most impactful topic for you as part of their School’s Out Make It Count campaign.

Updated 10/21: The University of Arizona led OSIRIS-REx mission made history with a five-second stop on the asteroid Bennu, Arizona Daily Star reports.

“It’s almost hard to process everything that’s happening right now,” said OSIRIS-REx principal investigator and UA professor Dante Lauretta over NASA’s live feed. “This is historic. This is amazing.”

Thank you arts organizations for providing virtual field trips and performances for students during this COVID-19 pandemic, says Peoria Arts Education.

Learn more about college preparedness and scholarship opportunities at Mesa Public School‘s Facebook Live event today at 4 p.m.

Confirmed COVID-19 cases in Arizona rose to 233,912 today from 232,937 yesterday, and 5,854 have died from the virus, said the Arizona Department of Health Services.

In Maricopa County, there are 151,527 confirmed cases of COVID-19, 27,128 in Pima County, 13,297 in Yuma County, 11,538 in Pinal County, 6,197 in Navajo County, 4,814 in Coconino County, 4,223 in Mohave County, 3,810 in Apache County, 2,961 in Santa Cruz County, 2,814 in Yavapai County, 2,075 in Cochise County, 1,777 in Gila County, 1,063 in Graham County, 606 in La Paz County and 82 in Greenlee County.

Balsz School District offers free developmental screenings for children and the next one is Oct. 28. Find out more below.

Avondale Elementary School District commends Avondale Middle School Principal Lillian Linn’s community building approach during National Principals Month.

Celebrating students’ cultures can help students in and out of the classroom, edutopia says.

Dysart School District congratulates to a West Point Elementary School student who was awarded third place in the 2020 Congressional Art Competition for District 8.

Planning what you’ll do for Halloween? Here are some tips from the City of Phoenix.

The City of Avondale has a drive-thru trick or treat event you might want to look into too.

Here’s your chance to ask school principals about how they’re ensuring the safety of students and staff, courtesy the virtual Capitol Hill briefing.

Register now for Be A Leader Foundation‘s Taking Steps Toward College Success Virtual Summit, Expect More Arizona recommends.

Here’s why your vote for school board members is so important, says Friends of ASBA.

Teachers, did you know that Adobe is offering free Adobe Spark classroom accounts for all eligible K-12 teachers? Check it out!

Updated 10/20: Schools across Arizona, like Rio Rico High School, adjusted their schedule today so students could take the ACT, a college readiness exam.

Wickenburg Unified School District welcomed students back to campus for in-person learning on Monday.

Glendale Elementary School District also welcomed students back to campus for in-person learning Monday.

The Arizona School Facilities Board has not done in-person inspections of schools since March 2020 when Arizona’s Stay Home, Stay Safe order began, and that has led districts to handle building ventilation upgrades related to COVID-19 on their own and in some cases with help from parents, The Arizona Republic reports.

Confirmed COVID-19 cases in Arizona rose to 232,937 today from 231,897 yesterday, and 5,837 have died from the virus, said the Arizona Department of Health Services.

In Maricopa County, there are 150,881 confirmed cases of COVID-19, 27,019 in Pima County, 13,284 in Yuma County, 11,476 in Pinal County, 6,149 in Navajo County, 4,789 in Coconino County, 4,211 in Mohave County, 3,798 in Apache County, 2,957 in Santa Cruz County, 2,798 in Yavapai County, 2,062 in Cochise County, 1,772 in Gila County, 1,053 in Graham County, 606 in La Paz County and 82 in Greenlee County.

Learn more about the role county school superintendents play in education in Arizona from Expect More Arizona.

Register now to take part in a free Zoom session on The Teen Brain, courtesy of Cave Creek Unified School District.

Fashion students at East Valley Institute of Technology work on their skills.

Tolleson Elementary School celebrates Eva Longoria during Hispanic Heritage Month.

Take a look at the National Center for Education StatisticsData Point that examines the race and ethnicity of public school teachers in the United States by the race and ethnicity of the students they teach.

MET bioscience students work on PGLO lab activities.

Here are some tips to include early math learning into your child’s play.

University of Arizona President Dr. Rob Robbins said early childhood education prepares young children for entering school and their future careers.

Sign up now for The Program for Infant/Toddler Care Virtual Trainer Institute that starts this month and is fully online, learn more thanks to WestEd.

Here are some facts about Peoria Unified School District‘s bond and override elections.

Goodwill of Southern Arizona celebrates their first graduate of their internship program.

Try some of these science activities while your kids are learning from home, courtesy of Education Next.

Kayenta Unified School District shared these safe Halloween ideas for families during the COVID-19 pandemic.

AZDHS amends COVID-19 school benchmarks Kayenta-Unified-safe-Halloween-ideas-781x1024

Earlier coverage

Oct. 7 – Oct. 19: What are teachers doing ahead of elections to support students afterwards

Sept. 23- Oct. 6: 44 A+Schools of Excellence named today

Aug. 25 – Sept. 8: Parents voice concern about online class size; school nurses prepare for students

Aug. 12 – Aug. 24: Students, teachers affected by Zoom outage

July 30 – Aug. 11: Parent organizes co-op for learners; group rallies for in-person school days after benchmarks release

July 13- July 30: Teachers prepare for digital learning and back to school

June 29 – July 12Video: Gov. says ‘Goal is to get children back to school when it’s safe;’ Schools lay out learning models

June 29: Video: Gov. delays in-person classes to Aug. 17 due to rise in COVID-19

June 15 – June 29: Video: Gov. pauses re-opening of some businesses as COVID-19 cases rise

June 24: Plan provides more funding, flexible instruction as schools re-open

May 26 – June 12: Increase in COVID-19 cases marks a new daily high

May 20 – 25: AZ Dept. of Ed releases COVID-19 guidance to schools for summer programs, back to school

May 11 – 19: Arizonans consider workplace safety, what back to school will look like amid COVID-19

April 26 – May 10: Stores re-open, COVID-19 testing blitz resumes on Saturday

April 8 – 25You can get tested now if you think you’ve been exposed to COVID-19

March 12 – April 7Coronavirus response: Cases rise; AZ Day of Giving