Arizona educators take the lead in mandated civics education - AZEdNews
Sections    Tuesday March 28th, 2023

Arizona educators take the lead in mandated civics education

Carol Anne Weech Teaches Government To Students At Pima High School In Pima, Ariz. Photo Courtesy Of Pima High School

Arizona educators and civics advocates are taking the lead in teaching a new generation of Arizonans about American government at a time when research finds a lack of civic knowledge and engagement in the United States.

While civics/government requirements have been part of the state’s social studies standards for many years, this is the first year that Arizona high school seniors must pass a 100-question civics test to graduate. Most students will have learned the concepts in the exam by the end of eighth grade, according to a report from the Arizona Department of Education.

Why is this important?

Students need to know how the U.S. government operates “so they can hold their elected officials accountable, and do their civic responsibility as adults,” said Carol Anne Weech, a U.S. government teacher at Pima High School in Pima, Ariz., and 2013 Rural Teacher of the Year for Graham County.

Sometimes it’s difficult for students to understand why government should matter to them, said Weech, who has taught history and government for the past 18 years.

“It’s hard to get them to understand why they need to vote… why it’s important to do jury duty or community service,” Weech said.” I love teaching what I teach, and I get frustrated that it doesn’t get the attention the other subjects do. It’s absolutely something that (students) need to know.”

That’s reflected in Arizona’s low rank in several measures of civic engagement, including voting in local elections, contacting or visiting public officials, discussing politics frequently, and attending public meetings, according to recent data from the National Conference on Citizenship.

Arizona educators take the lead in mandated civics education CivicsInfographic

Infographic by David Marino Jr./AZEdNews
For a larger version, click here

Arizona’s efforts to boost civic engagement

To change that, the Arizona Department of Education began The Excellence in Civic Engagement program in 2012 after a report by the Campaign for the Civic Mission of Schools found several deficiencies in civics education across the United States. The program promotes civic education in Arizona schools, and recognizes schools that excel at it.

“We wanted to create a program to support schools to teach research-based civic learning and civic engagement, and also to recognize schools that have been at the forefront of using civic learning,” said Tammy Waller, director of K-12 social studies and world languages at the Arizona Department of Education

The department recognizes schools that show effective implementation of the “six proven practices” mentioned in the Campaign for the Civic Mission of Schools report:

  • Classroom instruction on government, history, economics, law and history
  • Providing school programs that allow students to use what they learned in class to perform community service
  • Offering extracurricular activities
  • Encouraging student participation in school governance
  • Encouraging students to be involved in simulations of the democratic process

Another key focus is discussing current events and controversial issues in the classroom, particularly ones that young people see as important to their lives.

In a recent national poll of 830 educators, 43 percent of teachers said it was difficult to discuss national politics with students, while just 22 percent found race and ethnicity difficult to discuss, according to Education Week. That poll also found the division among students regarding national politics had increased over the past year, while division had not increased on gender, race, religion, immigration and LGBTQ issues.

The program also provides professional development, a Civics Learning Self-Assessment test on the website, hosts annual conferences and promotes other civic education activities.

Arizona’s civics exam

Arizona became the first state in the country to require students to pass a civics test to graduate from high school when Gov. Doug Ducey signed The American Civics Act into law in 2015. The legislation required that student’s answer at least 60 of the 100 questions on the U.S. Immigration and Naturalization civics test correctly.

The Joe Foss Institute, a Scottsdale-based non-profit which advocates for civics education across the country, pushed the civics test legislation in Arizona, as well as 16 other states and hopes to expand that to all 50 states, said Lucian Spataro, chief academic officer and vice president of legislative affairs for the institute.

Related article:
Research finds American’s  civic knowledge is lacking

The institute’s civics education initiative was developed in response to the “quiet crisis” in civics education, which is not being taught to the same extent that it once was due to the recent focus on STEM, Spataro said.

“Civics and history and government, previously taught on equal footing with the hard sciences, are no longer being emphasized,” Spataro said. “That’s playing out every day on the front page of the paper and communities across America where kids, students, young and old adults, really don’t understand much about how to govern the country, or what it means to be a citizen.”

Other initiatives to increase civic engagement

Other initiatives to increase students’ civic engagement include and Camp O’Connor, offered by the Sandra Day O’Connor Institute. explains legal issues in a simple and easy to understand way, and is part of the Arizona Foundation for Legal Services and Education. Subjects range from human trafficking, to legal issues that youth often deal with, including curfew laws, legal and social aspects to use of illegal substances, as well as the legal ramifications of bullying.

Camp O’Connor is a cost-free, merit-based summer program that will host 35 seventh- and eighth-graders from across Maricopa County and is run by the Sandra Day O’Connor Institute. It will be held from June 5 to 9 this year.

The camp helps students understand the importance of democracy, their role as citizens and helps young people build leadership skills.

The camp seeks to encourage civic knowledge and engagement at a young age, said Sarah Suggs, president and CEO of the Sandra Day O’Connor Institute.

Each morning, students learn about a subject, then they go to a location relevant to that subject in Maricopa County, and later that day return to participate in more educational activities related to the subject, Suggs said.

For example, on the day they learn about the judicial branch, participants will go on a field trip to the Arizona Supreme Court and have a question and answer session with Chief Justice Scott Bales.

“The average adult is not as civically engaged (today) as perhaps our parents were,” Suggs said. “I believe we are seeing the impact of that today.”

Suggs said civics education initiatives like Camp O’Connor are a way to escape the partisan discord and “lack of respect for our system” among Americans.

“We have to teach our children that that’s not the heritage of our democracy,” Suggs said. “There is a way to go about helping to solve society’s problems, and yet be civil, to help really understand all sides of an issue.”